The Cutting Edge

The official blog of Knife Depot

The Legend of the Bowie Knife

It must be long enough to be a sword, sharp enough to use as a razor, wide enough to use as a paddle, and heavy enough to use as a hatchet.

That quote from a historian perfectly sums up the versatility and diversity of design represented in the legendary Bowie knife.

There is no single item with a stronger connection to the American experiment than the Bowie knife. So where exactly did the Bowie knife come from and just what is a Bowie knife? We’re here to answer your questions.

What is a Bowie Knife?

Before we delve deeper into the history of the knife, here’s what the experts say is the consensus Bowie knife design.

I fooled you. There isn’t one. Different historians and knife enthusiasts will tell you different things. Some say any large knife with a blade exceeding five inches is a Bowie knife. Other says a Bowie knife must have a double-edged point.

In general, most would say a Bowie knife is a large fixed blade (although you will find the occasional folding Bowie like the Spyderco Slysz Bowie) with a clip point blade. A hand guard is often a staple of the Bowie but not necessary.

This Winchester Bowie is something that’s reminiscent of a knife people think you would see in the old American frontier.

I wouldn’t say it’s the quintessential Bowie knife because there are better quality versions out there, but this is what many see when they think Bowie knife.

The Man Behind the Knife

It’s impossible to trace the lineage of the famed Bowie knife without an earnest look at the knife’s namesake: James Bowie. Back in 2010, one of the contributors to this blog wrote a nice profile about Bowie, but it’s important to provide some context.

James Bowie, who was more commonly known as Jim Bowie, was born in Kentucky in 1796 and spent much of his life in Louisiana. His name is pronounced boo-E, but it’s not uncommon to see it pronounced bO-e (as in David Bowie). He was one of 10 children and born to a veteran of the Revolutionary War.

During Bowie’s childhood and adolescence, the United States was still a very young country at about 30 years of age. Society was still in flux and going through vast changes. When Bowie was born, the entire western portion of the country still belonged to the French and Spanish. But, with the Louisiana Purchase in the early 1800s, America started expanded westward.

Bowie and his brother Rezin joined the Louisiana militia in 1814 to fight the British in the War of 1812 but had missed the fighting by the time they arrived. After joining the Long Expedition to liberate Texas from Spanish control in 1819, he became a land speculator and illegitimately made money by selling land in the frontier.

The Origins of the Bowie Knife

Due to poorly kept history during that time, the true origins and early timeline of the iconic knife likely died nearly 200 years ago. But one account says Jim’s brother Rezin Bowie designed the first Bowie knife after cutting his fingers while skinning a rabbit in the mid 1820s.

Rezin had Jesse Clift make the Bowie, which was later described as a 9.5-inch knife that resembled a large butcher knife without a clip point or hand guard. Some of this stuff came from Rezin after the knife became famous, so it’s hard to separate the facts from the myth.

Most historians agree that the Bowie knife was never just a single design but an evolution of designs that the Bowies improved upon over the years. The knife evolved a little more before it was propelled to fame with Jim Bowie about a year later during the famous Sandbar Fight.

Sandbar Fight of 1827

By 1827, the roughly 31-year-old Jim Bowie already had a reputation as a badass frontiersman who you shouldn’t mess with, but it was the Sandbar Fight that solidified his reputation. This has been covered countless times, so I’ll just go over the basics.

On Sept. 19, 1827, a one-on-one duel between Samuel L. Wells III and Dr. Thomas H. Maddox took place on a sandbar in the Mississippi River near Vidalia, Louisiana. The two were settling a host of disputes. Duels were a serious matter that included negotiations, supporters, and the presence of surgeons. Bowie was there to support Wells. During the duel, the two men each fired two shots at one another but neither man was injured, so the duel was resolved with a handshake.

The fight was far from over, however.

The two parties went on to celebrate their survival when all hell broke lose. Although there’s a discrepancy in the accounts, we know a brawl erupted between the two factions. Two men were left dead and two were severely injured, including Bowie. He was shot and stabbed multiple times but still managed to draw his large sheathed knife and kill his rival.

Despite suffering gunshot wounds and stabs, Bowie managed to survive the incident. One doctor reportedly said, “How he lived is a mystery to me, but live he did.”

Aftermath of the Sandbar Fight

The press covered the incident and eyewitnesses told exaggerated tales about what happened that day. It captured the imaginations of the people and one man stood out among the others at the fight: Jim Bowie.

After the brawl, Bowie became a household legend and folk hero for his grit. Not long after, people began asking for their own large knife similar to the one Bowie carried and used during the fight. In some advertisements as early as 1830, manufacturers were selling Bowie knives.

A Bowie carried by John Brown at Harper’s Ferry in 1859.

The reputation of the American Frontiers helped proliferate the carrying of large knives and the Bowie knife was the gold standard, thanks to its versatile design.

The Bowie Knife Design

There are several variations of the Bowie knife before the late 1820s, but the iconic design you know today as the Bowie knife was solidified by the 1830s. Different sources say different things, but one account says that Arkansas blacksmith James Black made the most famous version of the knife based on a Jim Bowie design.

What is believed to be one of the first James Black Bowie Knives

It had an exceptionally long blade with a clip point and a sharpened edge at the top of the blade. Apparently that version had a 12-inch blade and a guard to protect the hand during combat. According to legend, Bowie returned to Texas with his James Black Bowie knife and killed three assassins with the weapon.

Black became the foremost expert on the Bowie knife, but over the years, more and more people started making their own Bowie designs based around the Black version.

Here’s a quick video overview from Daniel Winkler of Winkler Knives on the Bowie and its design.

Bowie Dies at the Battle of the Alamo

If Bowie somehow managed to die in a petty spat or died of typhoid like most people, his legend would have already been set in stone. But his legend grew greater due to his heroic death.

Bowie was a pivotal figure during the Battle of the Alamo in 1836. This was the site where forces for the Republic of Texas fought against the Mexican Army during the Texas Revolution.

The Republic of Texas had around 200 men against about 1,800 men from Mexico. The Mexican Army managed to overtake the Texans, but not before hundreds died in the process.

Bowie was a commander in the battle but was stricken with an illness during the siege. One historian says that Bowie was killed on his cot, “back braced against the wall, and using his pistols and his famous knife.”

The Alamo holds a special place in the heart of Texans. The fact that Bowie was there with his knife made the legend even greater.

The Modern Bowie Knife

As the country became less frontier and more suburban, the need for a massive fighting blade waned by the early 1900s. That doesn’t mean the Bowie knife faded into the sunset though.

There were a few major events that required the use of a versatile fighting knife, namely wars. Throughout American history, different military branches issued knives based around the Bowie knife. For example, the famous KA-BAR Fighting Knife is based on the design of a Bowie knife, replete with a large clip point blade and hand guard.

OKC Air Force Survival Knife with a Bowie-like design

Here’s more about the effectiveness of Bowie knives in the military from TrueWest:

Shortly after WWII, the Office of the Chief of Ordnance conducted a study of the use of knives and bayonets by American soldiers, finding that the issuance of a knife had not only been a morale builder, but also that the simple blade was most likely to be retained after discarding all other equipment. Further, the study revealed the knife’s effectiveness in numerous incidents in combat areas where the use of an edged weapon not only eliminated enemy soldiers who penetrated our defense lines, but also saved the lives of many a fighting man.

The same reason the Bowie knife excelled in the frontier (its versatility and effectiveness as a fighting tool) helped the Bowie knife prosper in the military.

These days, the general Bowie design has evolved and adapted over the years. A quick look through the Bowie knife category on Knife Depot reveals a diversity of designs and styles, from the large United Cutlery Highlander Bowie to the all-black KA-BAR BK9 Becker Combat Bowie.

2 Comments

  1. Thank you so much for this excellent amount of information on the most famous knife in American history. There are so many accounts, both historic and modern times film and book stories involving this knife that the actual history has been taken beyond the true information about this weapon.
    Thanks again.

    • Tim

      October 3, 2017 at 10:16 am

      You’re welcome. Aside from popular culture, part of the problem is that even at the time people were trying to exaggerate reality and create myths — including Bowie’s brother. Even some of the stuff in this post may not be accurate, but it’s as close to the truth as we can get I think.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

*

© 2017 The Cutting Edge

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑